Fish Eaters: The Whys and Hows of Traditional Catholicism


``Where the Bishop is, there let the multitude of believers be;
even as where Jesus is, there is the Catholic Church'' Ignatius of Antioch, 1st c. A.D



Monastic Sign Language



 


To follow the Rules of their orders and keep silence at the required times, monastics use hand signs to communicate their needs. These signs are akin to but different from the sort of sign language used by the deaf. They are gestural, lacking grammar and other characteristics of an actual language; rather, they constitute a lexicon, a vocabulary. There were exceptions, however; the Venerable Bede, for example, invented a finger alphabet that allowed for the signing of words, and such a system was used by Franciscans for some time.
 


 The Venerable Bede's Finger Alphabet
From The Tegrimi Compactus Manuscript. M.925. Fol 38r-39r
11th century



More prevalent, however, were systems of gestures -- which varied from Order to Order and throughout time -- that stood for entire words, a style still used today by Trappists and Cistercians. When exuberantly employed, this means of expression must look like what one would see from Italians in the streets of Napoli, and the following observation -- made in A.D. 1180 by a Welsh reformer after visiting monks at Canterbury -- demonstrates that:

There were so many signs being made by the prior to those serving and between the monks and those serving below with fingers, hands, arms and whispers that you would have thought yourself watching staged scenes or in the company of actors and jesters. It would be much more fitting to the modesty of monks to speak with human words than to use signs and whispers in such silent garrulousness.

As an Italian American, I don't see anything "immodest" at all in using the hands to speak, but moving along...

The following is a modern English translation of Monasteriales Indicia, an Anglo-Saxon list of hand gestures used in Benedictine monasteries in order to keep silence.1 The text, written in Old English and dating to the 11th century, is preserved in folios 97v-101v of the Cotton Tiberius A.iii manuscript, kept at the British Library. The complete text is below, but I've rearranged the items in order to classify them by type.




Monasteriales Indicia


These are the signs that one should use and earnestly follow with the help of God when silence is to be held in the monastery according to the Rule.


Ecclesiastical Persons

First, the abbot's sign is to set two fingers on your head and at the same time grab your hair.

The deacon's sign is that one should make a motion with one hand hanging, as if to ring a small bell.

To indicate the prior, raise your forefinger over your head, for that is his sign.

This is the steward's sign, for one to twist with his hand as if to unlock a lock.

The sign of the schoolmaster, who cares for the children, is for one to set two fingers on his eyes and raise up his little finger.

The churchwarden's sign is for one to set two fingers on his eyes and make a motion with his hands as if to pull a hanging bell.

If you would indicate something concerning the church, make a motion with your two hands, as if to ring a bell, then set your forefinger to your mouth and afterwards raise it up.

The sign of the bishop is to stroke with a hand on each shoulder downward over your breast in the sign of a cross.

If you would indicate something about a certain monk, whose sign you do not know, then take yourself by your own hood.

The sign for nuns is to set your two forefingers on your forehead, then stroke along your cheeks in the sign of the holy veil.

If you would have a masspriest who is not a monk, then stroke with your forefinger in the shape of a circle and, with your hand outstretched, make a sign as if you were blessing.

When you would have a deacon, stroke in the same manner with your forefinger and make the sign of the cross on your forehead in betokening of the holy gospel.

The sign of an unmarried priest is to stroke as we said before on your cheek with your forefinger.




Books

These are the signs of the books that one shall use at the divine service in church.

When you would like a gradual, move your right hand and crook your thumb, for this is how it is denoted.

If you would like a sacramentary, then move your hand and make a motion as if you were blessing.

The sign of the epistolary is for one to move his hand and make the sign of the cross on his forehead with his thumb, because one reads the word of God there as well as on the Gospel-book.

When you would have a troper, then move your right hand with your right forefinger turned forward toward your breast, as if you were using it.

If you would like an oblong book, extend your left hand and move it, then set your right (hand) over your left arm the same distance as the length of the book.



Liturgical Vestments and Objects

When you would have a superumeral, then stroke with your two forefingers, from the top of your head, underneath your cheeks and down your arms.

If you would have an alb, then move your garment back and forth slightly with your hands.

When you would have a belt, set your hands in front of you with your nails down and stroke to your two hips.

When you would have a stole, put your two hands on your cheeks and then stroke downwards.

If you would have a chasuble, stroke with outspread hands down over your breast.

When you would have a maniple, then stroke with the edge of your right hand over your left.

If you would have the offering, move your vestment back and forth, then raise up your two hands.

The sign of the chalice and the paten is for one to lift up his two hands and make the sign of blessing.

If you would have a sacramental wafer, bend your forefinger to your thumb.

When you would like wine, make a motion with your two fingers as if to remove the spigot from a tun.

If you would like a wine-horn, make a motion with your right forefinger on your left hand, as if you would pull a spigot, then raise your forefinger up to your head.

When you would have a censer, move your hand downwards and move it back and forth, as if swinging.

If you need tapers, blow on your forefinger and raise up your thumb.

If you would have a candlestick, blow on your forefinger and hold your hands locked together as if you had a candlestaff.

If you need a small candle, blow on your forefinger.

When you would like a flat candlestick, stretch out your left hand and set it perpendicular to your right.



Matins

These are the signs of the books that one uses at matins.

If you would have a Bible, move your hand back and forth, raise up your thumb and set your hand flat against your cheek.

When you need a legendary, move your hand back and forth, lay your right forefinger over your hand and lay your hand flat against your cheek.

If you would like some other book, containing a homiliary, then lay your right hand under your cheek and make a cross on your forehead.

When you need a psalter, stroke with your right forefinger on your left hand as if you would hold a large one.

The hymnal's sign is to move your open hand back and forth and raise up the little finger.

When you would have a large cross, lay your finger over your right finger and raise up your thumb.

The sign of the little cross is thus, but also to raise up the little finger.

When you would have a small candlestick, make a motion as we described before and raise up your little finger.



Commands and Requests

If you want to sit in the church because of illness, move your hand downward and with bowed head set your hand on your breast and ask leave for yourself.

If you wish a sitting man to rise, turn your hand and move it up quickly in stages.

If you wish him to sit, then turn it downward and move it down in stages.

If someone offers to a certain brother more of something, of which he has enough, then you turn his open hand down and with your hand stretched out, move it slightly.

If he would like to have what is offered, he should move his hand vertically down and move it slightly outwards in agreement.

If he does not want it, he should also move it slightly forward.



Places and Objects

If you would like to indicate something about the chapterhouse, set your hand on your forehead and bow a little bit as if you would ask forgiveness for yourself.

The sign of the bakehouse is to move your two hands locked together as if you were rolling out dough.


When you would like a small martyrology, move your hand back and forth, then lay your forefinger over your throat and raise up your little finger.

The sign of the Rule is to move your hand back and forth and stroke with your forefinger along your left hand, as if you were ruling.

If you would like a rod, move your fist back and forth as if flogging.

When you would have a whip, move your fist back and forth as we described before, and raise up your two fingers.

When you would have a lamp, raise up your right hand with outspread fingers and puff on your forefinger.



Refectory Objects

If you would indicate something about the refectory, then place your three fingers, as if putting food in your mouth.

When you would like a seat-cover, pluck your own clothes with two fingers, then spread out your hands and move them back and forth, as if to arrange a seat.

If you would like the folding stool for the mealtime reader, or another man, then clasp your hands together and move them the way you do when you fold it.

If you would like a cloth or napkin, set your two hands over your lap and spread them as if you were stretching the corners.

If you need a dish, raise up one hand and spread your fingers.

When you would have a loaf of bread, set your two thumbs together and your two forefingers one against the other.

If you need a knife, cut with one finger over the other as if carving.

If you need a spoon, move your hand as if you were eating with a spoon.



Food

The sign for boiled vegetables is to put one hand down by your side, as if you were scraping vegetables.

When you would like green vegetables, set your finger on your left hand.

If you would like a leek, make a motion with your finger, as if you would bore in on your hand, then move your open hand to your nose, as if you smelled something.

The sign of porridge is to move your fist back and forth as if stirring porridge.

When you would like pepper, shake with one forefinger over the other.

If you would like beans, set your forefinger up on your thumb's first joint.

The sign of cherries is to set the thumb on the front part of the little finger.

When you would like cheese, set your two hands flat together, as if pressing.

If you would like butter or fat, stroke with your three fingers on the inside of your hand.

If you would like milk, stroke your left finger with your right hand as if you were milking.

If you need eggs, scrape with your finger up on your left thumb.

When you would like salt, bring down your hand with three fingers together, as if you were salting something.

The sign of honey is to set your finger on your tongue.

When you would like fish, move your hand back and forth the way a fish moves its tail, when it swims.

The sign for an eel is to move the right hand, set it over the left arm and with the left hand stretched out, strike across it with the right, as if mincing an eel in order to stick it on a spit.

If you would like an oyster, close your left hand as if you had an oyster in your hand, and make a motion with a knife or finger as if to wrench open the oyster.

When you would like an apple, bend your right thumb to the middle of your hand, seize it with your finger(s) and raise up your fist.

If you would like a pear, make a sign with your fist as we said above, then join your fingers together the length of your hand.

When you would have a plum, close your left hand in the same manner and stroke along your fist with your forefinger.

The sign for cherries is to set your left thumb on your little fingertip, then pinch it with your right hand.

If you would like a sloe, set your thumb the same way and push your forefinger into your left hand to indicate the thorn that it grows on.

When you would have saltflesh for any reason, with your right hand pinch the lower part of your left, where the flesh is thickest and make a motion with your three fingers, as if you were salting.

When you want a cup or mug, place your hand downwards and spread your fingers.

When you would like a lid, lift your left hand closed together and then the right arched over the left as if covering a cup.

The sign for a large goblet is to raise up your right hand, spread your fingers, then lay your forefinger to your cheek and raise up your thumb.

If you would like a little drinking cup, raise up your three fingers, then lay your right forefinger to your cheek and raise up your little finger.

When you wish to drink, lay your forefinger along your mouth.

If you would like strained wine, make a motion with your right forefinger on your left hand, as if you would put a tap into a cask, then move your forefinger down and pinch it with your two fingers as if to wipe off a drop.

The sign for beer is to knead one hand on the other.

When you would like barm, move your fist as if you would pound plants and lay your forefinger to your lips.


Sleep

If you would indicate something about the dormitory, lay your right hand under your right cheek.

When you need a lamp, turn your forefinger to the ground, but also guard it and wet (it) in the middle with your forefinger, as if you would set a wick.

When you would have bedclothes, move your robe back and forth and lay your hand to your cheek.

The sign of a pillow is to stroke with your forefinger inward on your left hand in the sign of a feather and lay (it) to your ear.



Hygiene and Clothing

The sign of the latrine is to set your right hand flat over your stomach and use the sign for asking leave of your elder, if you want to go thither.

 If you would indicate something about the bathhouse, stroke with your right hand open over your breast and your stomach as if washing yourself.

When you would like to ask in signs if you might wash your head, stroke with an open hand on your hair, as if washing it.

If you need water, make a motion as if washing your hands.

When you would like soap, rub your hands together.

The sign of the razor is to put one forefinger over the other, as if carving and then to stroke your cheek with your finger as if shaving.

When you would like a comb, stroke with your fingers on your hair downwards, as if combing yourself.

If you would like an undergarment, take your sleeve in your hand and move it back and forth.

The sign of breeches is to stroke with your two hands up on your thigh.

When you would have a leg band, put your two hands around your shin.

If you would like hose, stroke upward on your shin with your two hands.

The sign for a fur garment is to stretch forth your left sleeve and pluck the inside with your left hand.

When you would like a cowl, move your sleeve back and forth and seize your hood.

If you need a short cloak to obey some order, then stroke edgewise with each hand over the other arm around the outside, where the short cloak's sleeves end.

When you would like a glove, stroke one hand along the other with an open palm.

If you would like slippers, set your forefinger upon your foot and stroke on both sides of your foot, in the manner which they are shaped.

The sign of socks is to set your forefinger in the same manner and raise up your thumb.

Then the sign of shoes is to set your forefinger right on your foot without any other signing.


The sign of shears is to move the forefinger and middle finger of your right hand on some cloth, as if to cut it with shears, or around your head as if barbering.

If you need a needle, fold the hem of your left sleeve in your right hand over your left forefinger and make a motion over it with three fingers as if sewing.



Writing

When you would like a stylus, set your three fingers together, as if you had a stylus, and move them as if you were writing, then beckon with your forefinger.

If you would like a small wax tablet, stretch out your two hands, set them down together and fold them up as if folding a wax tablet.

When you would like a large wax tablet, stroke with two fingers on the front of your breast as if you were erasing, then stroke your arm and set your hand on your left elbow.

 If you have no ruling stick, stretch your hand upward and stroke with your forefinger along your left hand as if you were ruling.

When you would like an inkstand, raise three fingers as if to dip and move your hand down and clench your fingers, as if you were picking up an inkstand.

The sign of a quill is to join your three fingers together as if you were holding a quill, then dip it, and move your fingers as if writing.



People - Non-Ecclesiastical

The sign of the king is to move your hand down, then seize your head on top with all your fingers in the shape of a crown.

The sign of the king's wife is to stretch your hand over your head and then set it on your head.

The sign of a layman is to take yourself with both hands by the chin as if taking yourself by the beard.

The sign of a laywoman is to move your fingers across your forehead from one ear to the other in the sign of a headband.



Footnotes:

1 From
Nancy P. Stork, Dept. of English & Comparative Literature, San Jose State University.

Back to The Religious Life
Back to Being Catholic
Index